Discussion about this post

User's avatar
City Zero's avatar

The three-way split you draw: not confusion, not ignorance, not Polanyi's tacit knowledge, is the sharpest part of this for me. All three of those categories describe a *relationship to language that hasn't changed yet*. But "something I do not yet have a word for" describes a relationship that's actively in motion: the attention itself is doing something across those thirty-two evenings, not just waiting.

So here's what I keep circling: is the *yet* doing real epistemic work, or is it mostly a promise the elder makes to keep attending? Put differently: if the word never arrived, would entry 24 have failed at something, or would it simply have stayed complete as a description of a boundary? I ask because that seems to decide whether "before the word" is a phase every practice passes through, or a state some things are honestly meant to stay in.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?